Scott Peterson: Decision Looms for Wife & Baby Killer’s Potential New Murder Trial, Amber Frey Ready to Testify

A California judge is scheduled to announce a decision next month that will determine if convicted wife and baby killer Scott Peterson will get a new trial.

Peterson will attend a hearing on December 2 at the San Mateo County Superior Court, along with his lawyers, Fox News Digital reports. Judge Anne-Christine Massullo is expected to rule on whether Peterson’s motion for a new trial will be granted.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, the California Supreme court was ordered to re-examine Peterson’s murder convictions last November after a jury member during Peterson’s 2004 trial committed “prejudicial misconduct.”

The juror, Richelle Nice, allegedly failed to disclose that she obtained a restraining order against her boyfriend’s former girlfriend in 2000 for harassment. The juror was pregnant at the time of the restraining order but denied any involvement in any crime-related incidents when asked during jury screening.

When jurors were asked if they were ever victims of crime or involved in a lawsuit, Nice answered “no” to both questions.

“Juror No. 7 committed prejudicial misconduct by not disclosing her prior involvement with other legal proceedings, including but not limited to being the victim of a crime,” the order read.

According to Peterson’s attorneys, Nice “worked hard” to get on the jury, the Los Angeles Times reports. She reportedly claimed she was willing to serve despite her employer telling her she wouldn’t be paid for time missed from work.

Nice later said she didn’t intend to be dishonest on the questionnaire and that she filled it “honestly and truly.”

Meanwhile, a woman Peterson was dating while married, Amber Frey, who was a key witness during his murder trial, has reportedly said she’s prepared to come back and testify against him again.

Check back for updates.


Peterson’s Death Sentence Overturned

In November 2004, Peterson was convicted of first-degree murder with special circumstances for killing Laci, and second-degree murder for killing Conner. He was sentenced to death.

In August, the California state Supreme Court overturned Peterson’s death sentence due to the “significant errors” in jury selection.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, although there was no physical evidence, prosecutors amassed a collection of circumstantial evidence that convinced a San Mateo County jury that Peterson murdered his wife and son.

According to court documents, the following circumstantial evidence was strong enough to lead to Peterson’s conviction.

  • Trained dogs picked up Laci’s scent at the Berkeley Marina, where Peterson claimed he went fishing when Laci vanished; her remains were later found close to the same area.
  • Peterson visited the crime scene repeatedly.
  • The tarp Peterson used on his fishing trip was covered in gasoline in his shed; gasoline is known to destroy DNA.
  • Another tarp was found buried in fertilizer, also known to destroy DNA, according to Dr. Henry Lee, who testified at Peterson’s trial.
  • Peterson told detectives he stopped fishing because it began to rain, although there was no precipitation at the Berkeley Marina on the day in question, according to the harbormaster.
  • Peterson claimed Laci was watching a cooking segment on television when he left their home on December 24, but the show he referenced aired on December 23.
  • Laci wore a diamond necklace, sapphire ring, and band each and every time she left her home. On the day she disappeared, the jewelry was left in her bedroom.
  • After Laci and Conner’s remains were found, authorities caught Peterson close to the Mexico border with his hair and beard dyed blonde, an identification that didn’t belong to him, several credit cards, clothes, knives, four cell phones, a rope, camping supplies, and around $15,000 in cash.
Scott Peterson 2021 mugshot
FILE – This Nov. 29, 2021 photo from the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, shows inmate Scott Peterson, who was convicted for the 2002 murders of his pregnant wife and unborn son. Peterson is expected to be resentenced to life in prison on Wednesday, Dec. 8, 2021, after the state Supreme Court ruled that his jury was improperly screened for bias against the death penalty. (California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation via AP, File)

Laci and Connor Peterson

Laci was eight months pregnant when she disappeared from the Modesto home she shared with her husband. Peterson became the primary suspect after he was caught in numerous lies throughout the investigation. Investigators also uncovered he was having an affair with Frey, a woman he met at a party.

The affair, according to prosecutors, was one of the most damning pieces of evidence against Peterson. Prosecutors argued that the affair alone didn’t automatically mean murder, but the information Peterson told Frey made him appear culpable.

Laci Peterson and Amber Frey
Laci Peterson and Amber Frey/Handout; AP Photo/Paul Sakuma, File

Prior to Laci’s disappearance, Peterson told Frey that his wife died previously and the upcoming holidays would be the first without her. He also told Frey that he never wanted children and that her daughter from a previous relationship would be enough for him.

On December 23, 2002, the day Laci disappeared, Peterson said he went fishing at the Berkeley Marina. In April 2003, investigators found Laci’s deteriorating body near San Francisco Bay, around eight miles north of Berkeley Marina. Connor’s body was found, with his umbilical cord still attached, nearby.

On April 18, 2003, police officers arrested Peterson near a golf course in La Jolla.

Reports indicate he was carrying $15,000 in cash, hundreds of sleeping pills, about 10 Viagra pills, multiple cell phones, and an identification card belonging to his brother. He was also found in possession of weapons including a firearm and a dagger.

Check back for updates.

ADDITIONAL Scott Peterson Coverage:

‘I couldn’t feel my feet on the floor’: Scott Peterson says he’s shocked he was convicted of killing Laci Peterson and unborn son, Conner

The real reason Scott Peterson killed his wife: Aphrodite Jones talks Peterson’s true motive and CrimeCon [EXCLUSIVE]

CrimeOnline Evidence Locker: Watch the Scott Peterson interrogation tapes

Scott Peterson’s last message to Laci revealed to the public for the first time

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Here is a related episode.

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most – your children.

[Feature Photo: Scott Peterson; Laci Peterson/Family Handout]