Newborn’s murder solved after 21 years: ‘Baby Michael’ was stuffed in a trash bag, tossed out a moving vehicle

Detectives in North Carolina have solved a cold case that broke their hearts 21 years ago: a newborn baby boy, umbilical cord still attached, stuffed in a plastic trash bag with the mother’s placenta and tossed out a moving vehicle.

A soldier found “Baby Michael” on the side of a rural road outside the town of Hope Mills on March 3, 1999. The boy, not even 24 hours old, had died of blunt force trauma.

On Thursday, the Cumberland County Sheriff’s Office announced the arrest of Deborah Riddle O’Conner, 54, who reportedly admitted she was the child’s mother.

How do you protect your children from predators? Join Nancy Grace and a team of world-class experts for the online course ‘Justice Nation: Crime Stops Here’.

Deborah Riddle O’Conner/ Cumberland County Sheriff’s Office

Moose Butler, sheriff of Cumberland County in 1999, dubbed the baby boy “Michael,” after the patron saint of law enforcement officers. A funeral service was held on March 30, 1999, and the infant was buried in a church cemetery.

“Detectives have never given up working on this homicide, and finally got a break in the case,” Cumberland County Sheriff Ennis Wright said Thursday.

Recently, they sent the baby boy’s DNA to a forensic genealogy service, and the company sent back a family line. Detectives found O’Conner 200 miles away in western North Carolina and, feeling she “was very likely Michael’s mother,” drove across the state to interview her.

When she told the investigators she was the baby’s mother, she was arrested and brought back to Cumberland County, where she’s been charged with first degree murder.

“You know, this person had an option,” Wright said, according to WSOC. “She had a choice but in this situation, the right choice wasn’t made.”

Officials said O’Conner has not revealed a motive for Baby Michael’s death, noting that she has several children older than the baby.

Cumberland County District Court Judge David H. Hasty set no bond for O’Conner during her first court appearance on Friday, the Fayetteville Observer reported.

WSOC spoke on Friday with O’Conner’s husband of 10 years, Charles O’Conner, who said he had no idea about the case, and his mother, Jean Dills.

“It’s just floored us,” Dills said. “We don’t know what to think.”

Charles O’Conner said he believes his wife is “completely innocent. She is not that type.”

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Listen to the latest episode:

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most – your children.

[Featured image: Baby Michael’s grave/Cumberland County Sheriff’s Office]