Ad
Ad

Carlie Brucia: Inmate Previously on Death Row for Girl’s Abduction, Rape & Murder Dies While Awaiting Resentencing

Florida officials said a man who was previously sentenced to death for abducting, raping, and killing an 11-year-old girl in 2004 died in prison on Monday.

The Bradenton Herald-Tribune reported that it is unclear how Joseph Smith, 55, died but the medical examiner’s office will perform an autopsy to determine the cause of death.

In 2004, Smith kidnapped Carlie Brucia as she walked home from a friend’s home in Sarasota. Four days later — and after Smith’s confession — Brucia’s body was found near a stack of cinderblocks behind a church. She was strangled and raped.

According to the newspaper, surveillance footage showed Brucia walking behind a car wash when Smith grabbed her.

While Smith was initially sentenced to death in 2006, in 2018 the Florida Supreme Court vacated the sentence on the grounds that juries must unanimously agree on the facts of the case and must unanimously vote for the death penalty. A jury voted 10-2 in favor of capital punishment for Smith. The Florida Supreme Court — and a 2016 U.S. Supreme Court decision — required the vote to be unanimous.

Smith was awaiting sentencing at the time of his death on Monday. The Bradenton Herald-Tribune reported that the Florida Supreme Court ordered his resentencing in May, months after ruling that vacated death sentences could not be retroactively reinstated.

Brucia’s father told the Bradenton Herald-Tribune that he learned of Smith’s death on Monday morning. The news outlet reported that Brucia’s mother died of a heroin overdose in 2017.

WWSB reported that Smith was considered a suspect in the 2000 slaying of Tara Reilly, 25, who was found nude in a pond behind a Walmart in Bradenton. Smith’s brother told the Bradenton Herald-Tribune that he believes Smith killed the woman.

“I wish he would have been a man and confessed,” Smith’s brother told the news outlet on Monday. “He never truly confessed, I don’t think, about Carlie and he definitely didn’t confess about Tara.

“He died a coward, that’s all.”

Reilly’s case remains unsolved.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Listen to the latest episode:

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most — your children.

[Featured image: Joseph Smith/Florida Department of Corrections; Carlie Brucia/Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office via Getty Images]